Project Initiation Document
At the beginning of a project, the project manager should produce a
document (PID) that
The PID should also include the following:
We shall look at each in turn
Project definition
What the project includes
- the scope of the application to be produced
- whether management will be able to choose from a range of options
- desk instructions, user training, data set up?
What the project does not include
- known exceptions
- links to associated systems
- staffing changes, accommodation, redundancy, careers advice
How everyone will know when the project is completed, e.g.
- hardware and software meet acceptance criteria and installed
- procedures agreed and tested
- desk instructions and user training delivered
- system running smoothly for a month
Decision making
Question: How do we decide whether to proceed with a project?
Question: If there are several ways of running a project, how do we decide
which option to choose?
Financial appraisal
Non-financial benefits
Risk
- technical feasibility
- political feasibility
- (management support)
- (user support)
Project justification
(Also known as financial appraisal)
Payback period
Choose the approach that recovers the initial outlay most quickly
Cash flow
Choose the approach that gives the most benefit (in the long run)
Discounted cash flow
Choose the approach that gives the most benefit
(but discount benefits in the future, as they aren't as valuable as
current benefits)
Discounted cash flow
Add up all the costs and benefits in each year for the duration of the
system's likely use (eg. 5 or 7 years)
Apply a "discount factor" to each year's cost or benefit
Add up the discounted costs and benefits
Choose the option with the greatest benefit
Discounted cash flow
Cost Benefit Analysis (£000's)
| Year |
0 |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
| Costs |
| Project costs |
-1200 |
|
|
|
|
| Maintenance |
|
-50 |
-50 |
-50 |
-50 |
| Benefits |
| Savings |
|
450 |
450 |
450 |
450 |
| Cash Flow |
-1200 |
400 |
400 |
400 |
400 |
| Discount factor |
6% |
| Discount rate |
1 |
.94 |
.88 |
.83 |
.79 |
| Discounted Cash Flow |
-1200 |
377 |
355 |
335 |
316 |
| Net Present Value |
186 |
If this ^ is positive, project will save money
Victoria University of Wellington, NZ have some detailed
notes on discounted cash flows.
Follow these for discussions about investment appraisal:
Project time-table
- Gantt chart

- Stage plan for second stage
- First stage is project initiation
- At end of first stage, managers will want to see details of the second
stage before giving go ahead to rest of project
- Task list for rest of project, with dates where possible
Organisation and responsibilities
Organisation of project
- who is in charge
- who is project manager
- who should ensure project quality
Responsibilities
- who is expected to do what
Why?
- To avoid omissions
- To prevent subsequent recriminations
- To give leadership and direction
Risk management
Risk is a function of
- how likely an undesirable event will happen
- how likely that event will cause loss; and
- how serious is that loss
Risk management tackles these by
- reducing the likelihood of the event happening
- reducing the likelihood of an accident or loss occurring and/or
- reducing the amount of loss
Procedure
Identify the risks
Devise a list of possible precautions
Select from list those that you consider cost effective
"Danger makes men devout" W.Baldwin (in "Beware
the cat"), 1584
Link to lecture notes specifically on Risk Management
Quality control
This will be discussed in more detail in
other notes, however...
It is important to state at the beginning of the project how you will
ensure the products will be assessed
- adherence to standards (whose? which version?)
- adherence to written procedures
- internal checks, peer reviews
- independent technical checks and tests
- integration test
- user test